Hydronic Heating & Cooling Specialists
Home/Products/Immergas vs Sime
Italian hydronic buyer's guide · both installed by AHHAC

Immergas Magis vs Sime Brava Slim: heat pump or condensing boiler?

Two of Italy's finest hydronic brands, two different approaches. The Immergas Magis is an all-electric air-source heat pump; the Sime Brava Slim is a condensing gas boiler. Here's how they compare on running cost, cooling, hot water and best-fit — and how AHHAC chooses between them.

Reviewed by AHHAC Technical Team · Updated 14 October 2026

The short answer

Updated

Immergas vs Sime is a choice between an all-electric heat pump and a gas boiler. Choose the Immergas Magis if you're building new or going all-electric, want summer cooling or have solar — it runs at COP 3.5–4.5 across 4–30 kW. Choose the Sime Brava Slim 30 BFR if you already have mains gas, existing high-temperature radiators and a tighter upfront budget — it reaches 93.7% efficiency. AHHAC installs and services both.

Magis efficiency
COP 3.5–4.5
Sime efficiency
Up to 93.7%
Summer cooling
Magis only
Sime output
28.1 kW

Reviewed by the AHHAC Technical Team — licensed plumbers & hydronic engineers, NSW Lic 262528C.How we write & review

Authorised supplier & installer
Maxa authorised supplierViessmann authorised installerImmergasSimeThermaSkirt™
Plumbing Lic 262528CABN 85 164 746 4906 showrooms · NSW · ACT · VIC · QLDEst. 1998

Head-to-head

Immergas Magis (heat pump)Sime Brava Slim (gas boiler)
TechnologyAir-source hydronic heat pumpCondensing gas boiler
Energy sourceElectricity (+ solar)Natural gas / LPG
EfficiencyCOP 3.5–4.5 (350–450%)Up to 93.7% net
Output range4–30 kW (3 chassis bands)28.1 kW (modulates to 13.1)
Running costLowest — near zero on solarTracks the gas price
CoolingYes — reversible chilled waterNo — heating only
Domestic hot waterYes (with a cylinder)No — needs a separate DHW source
On-site emissionsZero (near-zero with solar)Low-NOx (Class 5, <70 mg/kWh)
Best flow tempLow 35–55 °C (underfloor-ideal)High to 80 °C (radiator-friendly)
AU supply / certHunt Heating · AU compliantReece · AS/NZS 4552
Best forNew builds, all-electric, cooling tooGas homes, high-temp radiator retrofits

Indicative manufacturer figures; AHHAC sizes and quotes to your heat-loss calculation and fuel access.

Choose the Immergas Magis if…

…you're building new or going all-electric, you want the lowest running cost (especially with solar), you want one system that also cools in summer, or you're pairing with underfloor and modern low-temperature radiators. Its 4–30 kW chassis range covers apartments through to large homes and light commercial.

→ Immergas Magis heat pump

Choose the Sime Brava Slim if…

…you already have mains gas, want the lowest upfront cost, need high flow temperatures for existing high-output radiators, or want fast, on-demand heat. The Brava Slim 30 BFR is a compact, quiet, NOx Class 5, 93.7%-efficient condensing boiler certified to AS/NZS 4552.

→ Sime Brava Slim 30 BFR

Two Italian approaches to the same job

Both the Immergas Magis and the Sime Brava Slim exist to do one thing — heat water for your hydronic system — but they get there completely differently. The Immergas Magis is an air-source heat pump: it extracts heat from the outside air and lifts it to a useful temperature using electricity, delivering three-to-four-and-a-half units of heat for every unit of power. The Sime Brava Slim burns natural gas or LPG and recovers the latent heat in the flue gases to reach up to 93.7% efficiency. One is all-electric and can run on your solar; the other is a proven, high-output combustion appliance. Immergas is distributed in Australia through Hunt Heating; Sime through Reece.

Running cost, cooling and hot water

On running cost the Magis usually wins — a COP of 3.5–4.5 beats a boiler capped near 94%, and on solar the daytime cost approaches zero. The Magis also cools: it reverses to circulate chilled water in summer, so one unit covers both seasons (Immergas mandates Adey MC Zero inhibitor on cooling installs, which we include as standard). The Sime is heating-only and needs a separate domestic-hot-water source, whereas the Magis can make hot water with a cylinder. Where the Sime shines is high-temperature output and upfront cost: for a gas-connected home with existing high-output radiators, a condensing boiler is often the pragmatic, lower-capital choice.

How AHHAC decides

Because we carry both, the recommendation follows your home — not our stock. We start with a heat-loss calculation, then weigh fuel access (no gas, or going all-electric → Magis), whether you want summer cooling (yes → only the Magis can), emitter type (low-temp underfloor → Magis; existing high-temp radiators → Sime), and upfront budget (tighter → Sime). For the underlying economics read our guide to electric boiler vs heat pump hydronic heating, compare the wider market on our Maxa vs Viessmann vs Immergas page, or see the same heat-pump-vs-boiler decision for the German brand on our Viessmann Vitocal vs Vitodens comparison. You can also explore all our hydronic heat pumps and hydronic boilers.

Future-proofing

Choosing between Immergas and Sime with your next upgrade in mind

A hydronic system's pipes and emitters can outlast more than one heat source, so the smartest decision isn't only “which unit today” but “what will this home run on next time”. We talk this through with every client weighing the Magis against the Brava Slim.

If you choose the Sime now

For a gas-connected home with large existing radiators, the Sime is often the pragmatic, lower-capital choice. But we'll design it so a heat pump can follow later without a rebuild: we check that the radiators can still heat their rooms at lower water temperatures (upsizing the weakest one or two), fit the outdoor climatic sensor so the boiler already runs cooler on mild days, and note where a future outdoor unit could sit with the clearance it needs. That way your next replacement is a swap, not a redesign, and the money you spend on emitters today keeps working for you.

Gas policy is worth weighing as well. Victoria no longer allows new gas connections for most new homes and the ACT has stopped new gas network connections, so for new builds there the Magis is usually the only sensible path. In Sydney and Brisbane the choice remains open and comes down to tariffs, solar, the age of your existing system and whether you want cooling.

If you choose the Magis now, the main decisions are electrical and spatial. The largest band is three-phase only and needs generous rear clearance, so we confirm both at the site visit. If you'll want summer cooling, it's cheaper to insulate pipework and plan fan-coil condensate drains during the install than to add them later — our hydronic cooling guide explains why.

Either way, the emitters do the heavy lifting on comfort. Our hydronic radiator heating page covers radiator choice and sizing, and if you're upgrading an older system the hydronic retrofit guide sets out the steps from survey to commissioning.

Written from on-site experience by the AHHAC Technical Team.

Who designs & installs this

Licensed, in-house hydronic engineers — since 1998.

AHHAC's in-house design and service team — licensed plumbers and hydronic engineers (Lic 262528C) who have designed and installed 2,400+ hydronic heating, cooling and hot water systems across Australia since 1998.

We only specify equipment after a heat-loss and system-compatibility check, then supply, install and commission it with our own licensed plumbers to AS/NZS 3500 (plumbing) and AS/NZS 5601 (gas), register the manufacturer warranty and service it for the life of the system.

  • Sized from a heat-loss & compatibility check
  • Authorised Maxa, Viessmann & Immergas supplier
  • Supplied, installed & commissioned in-house
  • Manufacturer warranty registered for you
  • Six showrooms: NSW · ACT · VIC · QLD
  • Spare parts & servicing after install
262528C
NSW plumbing licence
85 164 746 490
ABN (verifiable on ABN Lookup)
2,400+
Hydronic systems installed
Since 1998
Operating in Australia
AS/NZS 3500
Plumbing & drainage standard
AS/NZS 5601
Gas installations standard
Common questions

Immergas vs Sime — FAQ

What's the difference between the Immergas Magis and the Sime Brava Slim?+
They're two different technologies from two Italian manufacturers. The Immergas Magis is an air-source hydronic heat pump — it runs on electricity, moves heat rather than burning fuel, reaches efficiencies of 350–450% (COP 3.5–4.5), and can cool as well as heat. The Sime Brava Slim 30 BFR is a condensing gas boiler — it burns natural gas or LPG at up to 93.7% efficiency and delivers high flow temperatures, heating only.
Which is cheaper to run — the Immergas Magis or the Sime Brava Slim?+
In most cases the Immergas Magis heat pump, because a COP of 3.5–4.5 means every unit of electricity delivers 3.5–4.5 units of heat — and on rooftop solar the daytime running cost falls close to zero. The Sime boiler's running cost tracks the gas price and is capped near 94% efficiency. Where gas is cheap and the system runs high radiator temperatures, the gap narrows.
Can the Immergas Magis cool my home as well?+
Yes — the Magis is reversible and circulates chilled water through the hydronic loop in summer (Immergas mandates Adey MC Zero inhibitor for cooling installs, which AHHAC includes as standard). The Sime Brava Slim is heating-only and cannot cool. If you want one system for both seasons, the Magis is the only option of the two.
Does either one make domestic hot water?+
The Immergas Magis can, paired with a hot water cylinder. The Sime Brava Slim 30 BFR is a heating-only boiler — it needs a separate hot water source (the boiler can heat a cylinder via a hydraulic separator, but it has no on-board DHW). We factor hot water into the system design either way.
Is a condensing gas boiler like the Sime still a good choice?+
Yes, in the right home. If you already have mains gas, want the lowest upfront cost, or need very high flow temperatures for existing high-output radiators, the Sime Brava Slim is an excellent, NOx Class 5, AS/NZS 4552-certified boiler. Many radiator retrofits of older homes are still best served by a condensing boiler.
Does AHHAC install both?+
Yes — AHHAC installs and services both the Immergas Magis (via Hunt Heating) and the Sime Brava Slim (via Reece) across our six showrooms in NSW, ACT, VIC and QLD. We run a heat-loss calculation and recommend the right one for your build, fuel access, climate and budget.
Heat pump or boiler for your home?
We'll size, spec and quote the right Italian system within 24 hours.
Get a quote →
Reviews

Trusted by homeowners, builders and strata across Australia

★★★★★
Rated 5-star across NSW · ACT · VIC · QLD
★★★★★

"AHHAC delivered our 22-zone underfloor system on time, on budget and to spec. The crew were tidy, the documentation was thorough, and the commissioning was textbook."

David Chen
Custom Builder · Mosman, NSW
★★★★★

"We've worked with AHHAC for 17 years. They've installed and serviced our hot water plant across three commercial buildings — and they pick up the phone on weekends."

James Holloway
Strata Manager · Melbourne CBD
★★★★★

"Three mobs quoted us; AHHAC's design was the only one based on a proper heat-loss calculation. The system runs beautifully — the others would've been oversized and expensive."

Janelle Smith
Homeowner · Robina, QLD
Last updated Content reviewed by the AHHAC Technical Team (NSW plumbing licence 262528C)Editorial standards